MLB’s best record wasn’t enough to keep a selfish Barry Bonds happy

Production isn’t enough for a contract

Imagine the salary a free agent could demand coming off of an All-Star year in which he led the league in walks and on-base percentage while slugging 28 homers. Teams would line up for his services, hoping to add that rare combination of offense to their lineup.

There was one such a free agent available in the off-season of 2008, but nobody signed him that winter. In fact he never played another inning in the major leagues.

Such is the life when you’re Barry Lamar Bonds.

Stories abound about of his black lounge chair and extra locker in his corner of the clubhouse at Pac Bell Park. His trial for obstruction and lying to a grand jury started last week with an admission of taking steroids and a far-fetched defense of never knowingly doing so.

With his prickly personality, and prima donna attitude, Bonds can be a tough guy to like. He was no fan of the media. And as it turns out, he wasn’t always a fan of official scorers either.

The early days of the defensive shift

During his playing days, Bonds pulled the ball with such consistency that teams employed a defensive shift. The Dodgers adjusted by placing their second baseman in short right field, a position sometimes called “rover” in a wiffle-ball game. The shortstop would field the spot normally occupied by the second baseman with the third baseman positioned up the middle like a shortstop.

It was a balmy 59 degrees on a Friday night in Los Angeles in mid-April, 2003. Dodger ace, Kevin Brown was on the hill and had had already given up four runs through the first three innings. The 54,799 on hand were not pleased.

In the top of the fourth, Brown retired the first two batters before Rich Aurillia hit an infield single to third. Up came Bonds. The Dodger defense shifted, putting second baseman Alex Cora on the right field grass, 25 feet deep.

Brown looked in to catcher Todd Hundley to get his sign, checked Aurillia at first, came set, and delivered to the plate. Bonds connected on Brown’s offering, scorching it to right field directly to Cora who missed the ball.

Would it be ruled a hit or an error?

Hit or error? It’s the official scorer’s call

The writers in the press box were unsure. Sure it was a play a major leaguer should make, but could Cora be charged with an error if the second baseman was playing rover in short right field?

That would be the call of Don Hartack, the official scorer. Hartack peered at the monitor in the press box for the replay, took his microphone, and confidently announced, “Error 4.”

“The ball was a rocket right at Cora,” Hartack recalled recently. “He (Cora) didn’t even have to move. It went right between his legs. That’s an error.”

For Hartack, it’s about the play, not the individuals or teams involved. It’s never personal. His sole mission is getting the call right.

In a post-game interview Bonds was miffed. He asked reporters how an error could be called on the play. After all, Bonds reasoned, the second baseman never should have been there in the first place.

Cora was charged with the error, but it was Bonds who was upset with the call.

“He (Bonds) wanted me to come down there (to the clubhouse) but I didn’t have any reason to,” Hartack said. “The ball he hit was an error.”

There was no convincing Bonds who complained about the call for the entire series. The Giants took two of three in Los Angeles and improved their record to a National League best 15-3.

Bonds didn’t want to talk about his team’s hot start. All weekend long, Bonds wanted to talk about that play.

No one wanted the baggage

He ended his career with 2,935 hits. The single-season and career home run champion wanted to play at least another year, and likely would have reached the 3,000-hit plateau.

So why didn’t any of the 30 Major League teams secure the slugger’s services? Perhaps they all came to the same conclusion about spending a season with Barry Bonds. Sure they would receive his considerable baseball talent, but they’d also have to endure all that came with it.

Reach Jim Smiley, the author of this story,

Be sure to check out, the internet’s leading website for the display of museum-quality baseball autographsCheck in at our Facebook page.

More Info About The Player In This Story

4 responses to “MLB’s best record wasn’t enough to keep a selfish Barry Bonds happy”

  1. Cooldrive says:

    Greatest player ever and a brave pioneer

  2. Brett says:

    He was a brave Pioneer in the use of performance-enhancing drugs.

  3. Pete says:

    If Bonds gets into the HOF, then everyone else from the steroids era should.
    If Bonds makes the HOF, then Pete Rose should also be enshrined.

  4. Ry says:

    Bonds is by far the best player I ever saw play the game. He was A HOFer before the round allegations. The league wasn’t testing at the time and it wasn’t banned, so no one from that era should be kept out bc we have no way of knowing who was on what

"Whoever wants to know the heart and mind of America had better learn baseball…"

~Jacques Barzun, 1954