Graig Nettles' 68.0 WAR, 2,225 hits, 390 homers, and 1,314 RBI put him in the Hall discussion
Graig Nettles is one of the most under-appreciated stars in baseball history. This is largely because he career concluded before the revolution in statistical analysis. Upon closer inspection, Nettles hits many high notes in both traditional and SABRmetric statistics. Playing the least-represented p
Graig Nettles' 68.0 WAR, 2,225 hits, 390 homers, and 1,314 RBI put him in the Hall discussion
Graig Nettles is one of the most under-appreciated stars in baseball history. This is largely because he career concluded before the revolution in statistical analysis.
Upon closer inspection, Nettles hits many high notes in both traditional and SABRmetric statistics.
Playing the least-represented position in Cooperstown, the third baseman totaled 2,225 hits, 1,193 runs, 390 homers, 1,314 RBI, 1,088 walks. The six-time All Star earned two Gold Gloves, six League Championship rings, and back-to-back World Series titles.
According to BaseballReference.com, Nettles’ career WAR and JAWS numbers are slightly above the average of the Hall’s 15 men at his position. Nettles’ career WAR is 68.4, his 7-year WAR peak is 43.0, while his JAWS and WAR/162 stand at 55.7 and 5.1, respectively. In those same categories, the average Cooperstown third baseman stands a shade below Nettles at 68.0/42.4/55.2/4.1.
Graig Nettles broke in with the Twins in 1967, playing part-time for three seasons in the Minnesota outfield. In December of ’69 he was part of a six-player deal that included Cleveland’s Luis Tiant.
During the 1970s Nettles averaged more than 25 homers and 80 runs batted in per season. Renown as a superior fielder, he totaled 22.4 defensive WAR in the decade. The first 9 years of the ’70s he posted overall WAR totals of at least 4.7 each season. In that run posted seasonal WAR numbers of 8.0 and 7.5 to go along with four seasons of 5.2 and above.
In 1976 his league-leading 32 homers pushed the Yankees to their first World Series appearance since the days of Mickey Mantle and Whitey Ford. Though they lost to Cincinnati’s Big Red Machine, New York returned to the Fall Classic in both ’77 and ’78.
Nettles posted career-highs in runs (99), homers (37), and RBI (107) in ’77 as the Yankees ended their 15-year World Series title drought. He followed that up by topping his career bests in hits and batting average in ’78. In the Fall classic his defense was on full display when he saved pivotal Game 3 with his glove.
Though Nettles has his 9th 20-homer season of the 70s in the final year of the decade, the Yankees dipped to fourth place in ’79.
On May 21, 1980, Nettles slammed his 269th career homer. The dinger pushed him past Brooks Robinson to make Nettles the all-time home run leader among American League third baseman. He still holds the mark today.
Nettles and the Yankees returned to the ALCS in ’80 and the World Series in ’81 but could not capture the title. His final season in the Big Apple was another 20-homer campaign in ’83.
The third baseman enjoyed his final productive season in 1985 when he made the last of his six All Star appearances. The Padres released him in 1986 after he hit .218 in 354 at bats. Nettles last two seasons came in ’87 and ’88 in Atlanta and Montreal. His final game came on October 1, 1988, 42 days after his 44th birthday.
Many advocate for Nettles’ inclusion into the Baseball Hall of Fame.
Shown here is a Yankee payroll check issued to Nettles on August 15, 1973.
The day before the check was issued, Nettles hit his 100th career homer
Here is the back of the check issued to Yankees third baseman Graig Nettles on August 15, 1973. The day before Nettles received the check he was the key man in New York’s 7-2 victory over the California Angels. In the bottom of the first at the Bronx, Nettles hit a single to center to drive in
The day before the check was issued, Nettles hit his 100th career homer
Here is the back of the check issued to Yankees third baseman Graig Nettles on August 15, 1973. The day before Nettles received the check he was the key man in New York’s 7-2 victory over the California Angels.
In the bottom of the first at the Bronx, Nettles hit a single to center to drive in Bobby Murcer for the Yankees second run of the inning. The Angels tied the score with two in the sixth.
Nettles came up again with two outs in the 8th and Murcer standing on second as the go-ahead run. He delivered the decisive blow a two-run homer, deep over the right-field wall.
The Yankees added three more in the inning to break the game open 7-2.
Shown here is the back of the check. Nettles’ signature appears at the top of the check in the form of his endorsement.
The Yankee-Red Sox rivalry was alive and well during Nettles time in New York
Perhaps the greatest rivalry in all of baseball is between the New York Yankees and the Boston Red Sox. When Graig Nettles played, the rivalry was alive and well. On May 20, 1976 the two teams squared off at Yankee Stadium. New York led 1-0 heading into the bottom of the 6th inning. With two out, Lo
The Yankee-Red Sox rivalry was alive and well during Nettles time in New York
Perhaps the greatest rivalry in all of baseball is between the New York Yankees and the Boston Red Sox. When Graig Nettles played, the rivalry was alive and well.
On May 20, 1976 the two teams squared off at Yankee Stadium. New York led 1-0 heading into the bottom of the 6th inning. With two out, Lou Piniella and Nettles reached base with back-to-back singles.
Otto Velez smoked a line drive base hit to right field fielded. Third base coach Dick Howser waved Piniella home. Boston right fielder Dwight Evans came up with the ball and threw a laser to catcher Carlton Fisk. Piniella crashed into the Boston backstop who tagged him out.
Nettle’s describes the action: “It started with a collision at home plate with Piniella and Fisk and they came up fighting. The year before we’d had a fight in Boston and Bill Lee said the Yankees fought like Times Square hookers. I just wanted to let him know we had some tough hookers in Times Square.
“He was in on the pile and I saw him taking swings at people. I threw him on the ground and he told me he’d get me next time.
“I said, ‘Let’s not wait ’till next time, let’s do it now.’
“So I popped him in the eye a couple of times. I remember some of their players coming up to me the next day congratulating me so they wouldn’t have to put up with that guy.”
Lee suffered a dislocated shoulder and a bruised ego. He didn’t pitch again until July 15th. On July 23rd he faced the Yankees for the first time since the brawl. Nettles went 2-for-4, including a two-run homer off of Lee as the Boston left-hander gave up 7 earned runs in four innings of work.
Shown here is a 1973 Topps card signed by Bill Lee. In ’73 the left-hander moved to the starting rotation he put up career-best numbers in wins, strikeouts, ERA+, and WAR.
Nettles had an indirect hand in Ken Griffey Jr.'s hatred of the Yankees
Ken Griffey Jr. grew up in and around big league clubhouses. His father and namesake showed him the inner workings of baseball. Not all of the early education was positive. One lesson Junior learned at an early age stuck with him forever. His father and namesake broke in with the Reds in 1973 and w
Nettles had an indirect hand in Ken Griffey Jr.'s hatred of the Yankees
Ken Griffey Jr. grew up in and around big league clubhouses. His father and namesake showed him the inner workings of baseball.
Not all of the early education was positive. One lesson Junior learned at an early age stuck with him forever.
His father and namesake broke in with the Reds in 1973 and was a key cog in back-to-back World Series champions. After 9 seasons in Cincinnati, he was traded to the New York Yankees. George Steinbrenner promptly signed him to a six-year deal.
During Griffey’s time in the Big Apple, Junior learned he never ever wanted to play for the Yanks.
“I came up to visit my dad. It was just me and him and got to the ballpark early. I’m sitting in the dugout. The security guard comes over and says, ‘Hey, George [Steinbrenner] doesn’t want anybody in the dugout.’ My dad was like, ‘What? That’s my son.’
“So he goes, alright, ‘Hey go to my locker. But before you go, look at third base.’
“It’s Craig Nettles’ son taking ground balls at third base.
“And at that time my dad was 38 years old and he’s like, ‘I ain’t fightin’ this no more. I got somebody a little younger and a little bit better.’
“You know there are certain things that a dad drills into you as a kid that just stick with you. And that was one of them.”
Junior never forgot the double standard imposed by Steinbrenner. Throughout his career he said he’d rather retire than play for the Yankees.
In this letter, he reflects on the beauty of baseball. “People ask me my favorite part of the game and I tell them: the whole thing. It’s making that impossible catch; it’s gunning down a speeding baserunner at home plate from deep in centerfield. And it’s the feeling you get when you see your pitch. Then you hear the crack of the bat and you know the ball is gone.”
Watching this guy play 3rd was a privilege for us Yankee fans!! An all-around great player with excellent career stats and you never heard his name considered for the HOF. Something’s rotten in the state of Denmark, people!!
He hit 390 HR. Coming up 10 HR short of 400 and, the low-ish batting average compared to most HoF inductees is very difficult to overcome for someone of his era.
Been watching baseball since 1970. I’ve seen a lot of players come and go. Nettles was a winner. Hit for power, best fielding 3rd basemen I’ve seen, and was a leader. If he’s not in the HOF the HOF has no credibility. Wait…
Watching this guy play 3rd was a privilege for us Yankee fans!! An all-around great player with excellent career stats and you never heard his name considered for the HOF. Something’s rotten in the state of Denmark, people!!
He hit 390 HR. Coming up 10 HR short of 400 and, the low-ish batting average compared to most HoF inductees is very difficult to overcome for someone of his era.
Been watching baseball since 1970. I’ve seen a lot of players come and go. Nettles was a winner. Hit for power, best fielding 3rd basemen I’ve seen, and was a leader. If he’s not in the HOF the HOF has no credibility. Wait…