Hall of Fame debates often split the room. Should voters reward peak dominance or marathon careers?
If peak performance rules the argument, Ron Guidry storms the discussion. The man known as Louisiana Lightning burned through the American League. From 1977 through 1979, Guidry owned AL hitters with ruthless efficiency.
He averaged 33 starts and nearly 20 wins per season. Complete games and shutouts flowed like routine work. Guidry piled up strikeouts and crushed expectations.
Those three seasons produced 20.9 WAR, tops among American League pitchers. No rival touched his combined value during that stretch. Advanced metrics loved him just as much as box scores.
Guidry led the league in fielding-independent pitching all three seasons. He topped the AL in ERA twice. He also led once in wins, shutouts, WHIP, and hits allowed per nine. Every category told the same story.
Critics sometimes point to brevity. Guidry answered by sustaining excellence into the 1980s.
He posted a 5.3 WAR season and several more elite campaigns. Three seasons reached at least four WAR. Five seasons cleared three WAR. Seven seasons delivered 2.5 WAR or better.
Guidry didn’t just flash brilliance. He reinforced it year after year.
The card shown here, a 2005 Ultimate Signature Decades edition honors that dominance.
One of my favorite Yankees! Love the 1978 Team!
Ron Guidry is definitely a HOF’er, no doubt about it and he’s probably more eligible than some who’ve already been elected. C’MON MAN, Ron Guidry for HOF now! Loved watching Louisiana Lightning pitch for Yanks, a team player!
I watched the last game of the 1977 season for the bombers. Gator was on the mound with I think a record of one and one.That game I saw Koufax pitching, I new in my heart he was going to have a good 1978.But I never thought it would be one of the best ever in history.
He was also a heartbeat away from Cy Young Awards in 1979 and 1985. He was dominant in 1981 and 1983. If he added one more Cy Young, I think he would be in. The Roberto Clemente award seriously adds to his legacy. Every kid in the NY Metro wanted to be like Ron Guidry in the late 1970s and early 1980s.