Jerry Reuss played 22 big league seasons, for eight different teams and 17 managers. Fifteen of those campaigns he suited up for the Pirates and Dodgers. Though he pitched for just one skipper in Los Angeles – Hall of Famer Tommy Lasorda – he threw for three iconic skippers in Pittsburgh.
When the Pirates acquired Reuss in October of ’73, he had 47 wins and 48 losses. Under two-time World Series championship Danny Murtaugh, he flourished. In the left-hander’s first season in Pittsburgh he matched his previous career high with 16 wins. His 3.50 ERA was nearly a quarter of a run better than any previous season. Reuss’ performance helped the Pirates win the Eastern Division crown.
Reuss improved on that in ’75 by going 18-11 with a 2.54 ERA that translated to a 139 ERA+ as Pittsburgh repeated as division champs. In 1976 Murtaugh announced he was retiring at season’s end.
The Pirates had their eye on Oakland’s Chuck Tanner as Murtaugh’s replacement. Athletic’s owner Charlie Finley told them they could have Tanner for a price: three-time All Star catcher Manny Sanguillen and $100,000. Pittsburgh completed the deal on November 5th. In ’77 Tanner became Reuss’s sixth manager. Jerry pitched two seasons for Tanner before a trade to Los Angeles.
Reuss returned to the Steel City 13 years later for his his final big league season. A September call up for Jim Leyland’s 1990 Pirates, Reuss appeared in four contests. That made him the first to play for the three Bucco pilots, Murtaugh, Tanner, and Leyland.
Reuss’s Pirates team from 1975-1987 John Candelaria duplicated the feat when returned to Pittsburgh to play for Leyland in 1993. Candy and Jerry end up as the only two to play for the Pirates managerial trio.
In this handwritten letter Tanner writes about 1979 World Series MVP Pops Stargell. Reuss, Tanner, Candelaria and Stargell shared the Pittsburgh dugout in 1977 and ’78.
Tanner writes, “Willie was the leader of our team on the field and off the field. He was like a 10 diamond karat ring on your finger to manage. What an honor I had.” The Pirates manager then pens his name at the bottom. Also shown is an autographed Donruss baseball card of the Buccos’ skipper.