The Cy Young Award was originated in 1956 to recognize pitching excellence. Through 1966 it was given to the singular best twirler in the major leagues. Then in 1967, it was expanded to honor a pitcher in each league.
Through the award’s first 70 years 22 pitchers earned multiple nods. Half of them picked up the honor a third time.
Justin Verlander is one of the 11 to capture the Cy at least three times. Baseball writers bestowed it to the ace in 2011, 2019, and 2022. The American League pitching Triple Crown winner in 2011, Verlander won 24 games with a 2.40 ERA and 250 strikeouts. In addition to the Cy Young, his performance got him the AL MVP. Verlander also led the league in victories in each his two other award-winning campaigns.
Roger Clemens is the most-decorated recipient with 7 Cy Young plaques. Left-hander Randy Johnson is next with 5 nods. A pair of Cooperstown men, Steve Carlton and Greg Maddux won four each. Along with Verlander, Pedro Martinez, Max Scherzer, Clayton Kershaw, Jim Palmer, Tom Seaver, and Sandy Koufax have three each.
Shown here is a 1961 Topps card autographed by Koufax and LA teammate Johnny Podres. The Left Arm of God earned his trio of Cy Young Award in his final four years with the Dodgers from 1963-1966. Koufax is the first hurler to earn three Cy Youngs.