HoFer Bert Blyleven gave Don Mattingly an earful in ’84!

After fourteen years on the ballot, Bert Blyleven got elected in 2011, his final year on the Writers’ ballot. The first Dutch-born inductee, Blyleven was a practical joker off the field, and a competitor on it.

Renowned for having one of the game’s best curveballs, Blyleven could also bring the heat. Just ask former Yankee Don Mattingly.

The first time the two squared off was in August of 1984 at Cleveland’s Lakefront Stadium.

Blyleven was in the midst of one of his finest seasons. The Dutchman went 19-7 with a 2.87 ERA that year and finished fourth in the American League in strikeouts.

Mattingly was near the apex of his career, finishing the year as the A.L. batting champ, leading the league with 207 hits, and 44 doubles.

“The first at bat, I hit a seed, a one-hopper right at the first basemen,” Mattingly said.

Feeling confident Mattingly came up for his second at bat ready to do some damage.

“I was like all right, I’m going to hit him hard again,” Mattingly recalled.

Did the confidence pay off?

“The first pitch was right at my chin and knocked me down on my ass,” said a smiling Mattingly. After dusting himself off, the slugger dug in for the next offering with added incentive. “The next pitch was in the same place, except that one hit me,” said Mattingly, shaking his head. “He was tough, I’ll tell you.”

The play-by-play of the game on August 12, 1984, backs up Mattingly’s memory. In the slugger’s second at bat of the day, the pitcher indeed plunked him.

Blyleven followed that up by striking Mattingly out in the seventh.

In his final at bat of the game, Mattingly got a measure of revenge with a ninth-inning single. The next batter, grounded out as Blyleven recorded a five-hit shutout.

Mattingly finished with 51 career plate appearances against the Cooperstown-bound Blyleven, hitting .409 with five walks, ten runs batted in, and yes, that one hit by pitch in ’84.

“I guess I hit him all right,” Mattingly said. “I’ll tell you what, he was a competitor.”

Reach Jim Smiley, the author of this story, CooperstownExpert@gmail.com

Be sure to check out CooperstownExpert.com, the internet’s leading website for the display of museum-quality baseball autographs.

More Info About The Players In This Story

3 responses to “HoFer Bert Blyleven gave Don Mattingly an earful in ’84!”

  1. Mark johnson says:

    Great competitors fun to read this stuff

  2. these guys were ballplayers back then. Can you imagine taking Bert out of a game because he had almost thrown 100 pitches. No way.

  3. Jon says:

    Nice article…Cleveland MUNICIPAL Stadium, on Lake Erie…expected funny, but got interesting…great players don’t back down and thrive on the competition…it’s a TEAM sport, but when a hitter is in the box, it is Man on Man = gladiators…stay well Jim!!

"Whoever wants to know the heart and mind of America had better learn baseball…"

~Jacques Barzun, 1954